Looking for Where to Stay in Caye Caulker? We visited Caye Caulker in 2024 during our second trip around the world, right after Mexico and before Guatemala. This laid-back little island in the Belizean Caribbean won us over with its motto Go Slow, sandy streets, incredible sunsets, and a vibe that invites you to disconnect from the world.
Caye Caulker is small, but choosing where to stay makes a difference—whether you want to be close to the dock, restaurants, the beach, or simply in a quieter spot.
In this guide, we share with you the 3 best areas to stay in Caye Caulker, with hotel recommendations tested and approved by travelers like us.
Table of Contents
You might be interested in these posts
Best Areas to Stay in Caye Caulker
- Playa Asuncion – The island’s center and main beach, ideal for those who want everything at their doorstep.
- Front Street – Coastal area near the dock, with many restaurants and cafés.
- North Side – More peaceful and exclusive, with resorts and stunning ocean views.
Playa Asuncion
This is where most travelers stay. You’re close to the main beach, the dock, and everything essential: markets, cafés, bars, and water activities. A great area for those who want to be in the heart of the island.
- Budget: Caye Caulker Plaza Hotel – Central location, simple but comfortable rooms, excellent price for the area.
- Mid-range: Jan’s Hotel – Just steps from the beach, with modern rooms and a family-friendly atmosphere.
- Luxury: Coral View Hotel & Resort – One of the highest-rated hotels on the island.
Front Street
One of the main seaside streets, perfect for those who want to be close to the best restaurants and the dock’s activity. Despite the central location, the atmosphere is relaxed and ideal for unwinding.
- Budget: Rainbow Hotel – Simple, well-located, and good value for money.
- Mid-range: Beach Club Budget Rooms – Features an outdoor pool, private beach area, and a bar.
- Luxury: Barefoot Beach Belize Resort – This is where we stayed, and we loved it! Spacious cabanas, a pool, free bikes, and a deck with hammocks to watch the sunset.
North Side
More secluded, this part of the island is perfect for those seeking tranquility, away from the hustle and bustle. You’ll have direct access to the sea and fantastic views, with more exclusive and romantic accommodations.
- Budget: Island Magic Beach Resort – Well-located, with a seaside pool, restaurant, and spacious rooms. An excellent choice for those seeking comfort on a budget.
- Mid-range: Bay Towers – Modern apartments with a balcony and sea view, ideal for longer stays or those who want more space and independence.
- Luxury: El Ben Cabañas – Elegant wooden cabins with an infinity pool, bar, restaurant, and a romantic seaside atmosphere.
Tips for Choosing Where to Stay in Caye Caulker
- Playa Asuncion is perfect for those who want to be in the center of the action, close to everything.
- Front Street combines a good location with tranquility.
- North Side is ideal for relaxing in style, with more exclusive options.
- The island is small and easily explored on foot or by bike, but remember: the north side requires a ferry or speedboat.
- Many hotels offer free bike and kayak rentals—ask before booking!
FAQs – Frequently Asked Questions
What is the best area to stay in Caye Caulker?
It depends on your travel style. Playa Asuncion is more central, Front Street is quiet but well-located, and North Side is more exclusive and romantic.
Is Caye Caulker safe for tourists?
Yes! The island is super safe and peaceful. You can walk at night without any issues, but as always, use common sense.
How do I get around the island?
On foot, by bike, or in golf carts (which you can rent). The island is small and easy to explore.
Where did you stay in Caye Caulker?
We stayed at Barefoot Beach Belize Resort on Front Street. We loved the location, the relaxed vibe, and details like the hammocks on the deck.
When is the best time to visit Caye Caulker?
The best time is between December and May, during the dry season. Avoid September and October, which are rainier.
